Interlaken

Blue Jay Plumbing and Heating

4.9 of 5

Average of 56 Google reviews

Positive and negative reviews

  • Positive 55 reviews, 98% of all reviews
  • Negative 1 review, 2% of all reviews
  • Not counted 0 reviews, 0% of all reviews

Google reviews of 4 or 5 count as positive. Google reviews of 1 or 2 count as negative. Google reviews of 3 are not counted.

AI-generated summary

Summary of reviews

AI wrote this summary from the reviews below. It can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

What reviewers like

  1. Skilled, knowledgeable work

  2. Reviewers praise prompt responses and timely service

  3. Professional, courteous service

  4. Reviewers praise clear communication and explanations

  • Written reviews used: 54
  • Made on October 24, 2026

AI reads the Google reviews shown on this page, up to 300. When there are more, it reads a random sample of 300 with the same mix of star ratings as all the reviews. Each point is something at least 3 reviewers say. It shows how many, and you can open their reviews. Complaints are what reviewers report, not our verdict. We check serious ones before showing them. AI can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

Call (714) 713-2956Visit website

License record

Not checked by FairPipes yet

We do not have license records for New York yet. Look up this business on the state licensing board's website.

Details

Hours
  • Every day Open 24 hours
E-mail
E-mail Blue Jay Plumbing and Heating

Social media

Hours as listed on Google; we have not checked them.

Reviews

From Google

Andrew Merrill 5 of 5

New Great price Excellent service. Spent time with me on the original call to help trouble shoot, then followed up with an apt to see scope of job. Punctual… Explained each step that would be taken. Went over work done when completed. Up front information on pricing. Pointed out areas of concern (that will need to be addressed down the road). Arrived prepared for job. Did not waste any time. Services Toilet repair, Faucet installation, Service not listed

From Google

Dan de Kadt 5 of 5

New Have only had really positive experiences with Garrett Jay over the past two months. He has: - installed a smart water shutoff valve (Moen Flo) - re-engineered multiple wastewater pipes that were running against grade - installed a water filter - fixed a few small bits and pieces - saved me when a gas line was not capped Thank you Garrett for your careful work, strongly recommended to anyone looking for a plumber.

From Google

Carey Cleveland 5 of 5

Got out here quickly and did a great job at a very reasonable price. Services Toilet repair, Plumbing leak detection

From Google

Janna Solomon 5 of 5

Reasonable price Great experience with Blue Jay team! Their work was top quality and they mastered some difficult projects for me! I trust them. Services Plumbing pipe repair

From Google

Cindy Linton 5 of 5

Reasonable price | $200–300 So glad I hired Blue Jay Plumbing to take care of a clogged toilet drain. Had called several places and found that the some plumbers who advertise this service don’t actually do this service so I was really happy to find out that Blue Jay was fully ready to handle the job. Since this wasn’t an emergency situation, we were able to wait a few days for them to fit us into their already very busy schedule. The young man who arrived, went straight to work taking care of the problem, which required removal of the toilet and reseating after the clog was cleared. He was knowledgeable, professional, efficient, polite and personable. I highly recommend this local company that is working hard to provide their community with a quality choice for plumbing services. Thank you Blue Jay Plumbing! Services Drain cleaning

From Google

Robert Carroll 5 of 5

Garrett Installed a Furnace and New Smart thermostat for me last year when my heat went down in February and it was sub Zero outside with a Pregnant Wife. He worked quickly to install it and was very professional. He converted my new gas dryer last year as well and was just as quick and professional with that. Lastly he installed a vented wall unit in my garage this winter and had me up and running with heat in no time. I Highly Recommend Garrett and the Blue Jay Plumbing team for all your HVAC and Plumbing needs.

From Google

Mulder Factor 5 of 5

Garrett and crew at Blue Jay Plumbing are wonderful. We have used their services numerous times at our OLD farm house. Exceptional quality work, & quick, direct and personable communications, and prices fair. Thank you. We are now lifelong customers.

From Google

A D 5 of 5

Garrett has been so awesome while dealing with a tankless water heater issue (came with the house). With many trips to our house to troubleshoot, Garrett had a positive attitude and he was communicative. As a stressed homeowner, contractor vibes can make or break a relationship. Garrett's vibes were positive and collaborative. We ended up going the traditional water heater route with a quick turn around time. I would recommend Blue Jay Plumbing and Heating for your residential needs.

From Google

Shonte Ransom 5 of 5

Single mom here with 2 kids and a broken water heater during the winter!!! Mr. Jay initially scheduled me for a week out but ensured he would try to fit me in sooner ...AND HE CAME WITHIN 3 DAYS!!! I was very impressed by the knowledge and expertise of Mr. Jay. He arrived within the time frame and called me prior to arrival. He demonstrated professional behavior throughout his entire work. He was polite, pleasant and answered in details all the question I posed to him. He was meticulous in ensuring all the pieces were connected and sealed appropriately. At the end of his work, he made sure to collect all the throw away pieces and that the place was clean. I highly recommend him and it was indeed a pleasure having him do the job. Thank you so much Mr. Jay. I definitely appreciate your service!

From Google

Rose Riley 5 of 5

Garrett of Blue Jay, plumbing and heating, in my opinion is the best in the business… Long ago, I used a couple different plumbers, And then I found Garrett, and I’ll never use another… He is always quick to respond, and he will get to you as soon as he can ( which is quick )… I have used his service for many projects, and I have always been 100% satisfied… And I have recommended him, to a half a dozen other people, and they too are 100% happy… He is knowledgeable and kind and courteous, Thank you for all you do!!!

From Google

Nikki Parish 5 of 5

Garrett Jay is hands down the most reliable, courteous, professional and prompt gentleman you could possibly hope for. My late father utilized his services, and he has done work on my home both before I acquired it and since I moved in. He has saved the day, every time, with AC issues, furnace problems and plumbing dysfunctions. Most recently, my MIL needed a secondary heat source installed in her wood stove heated farm house, with time being of the essence. Thanks to Garretts extensive knowledge of all things heating and his passion for serving his community as promptly as possible, he beautifully installed propane heating in her home right before Christmas. Thanks to Garrett, my MIL was able to travel to NC in time to be by her sister's side before she passed on. He has always gone above and beyond for his community, and I cannot speak enough of his professionalism, prompt service, and ability to relay to his customers exactly what the problem is and how he is going to repair/install it. You would be hard pressed to find another owner operated company that loves his community and always brings his A game to everyone I know who uses his services (and there are many!) This man is the one you want to call if you ever have any heating/cooling/plumbing issues. He'll get the job done, often times even stopping by after the job is done just to make sure everything is running smoothly like he did for my MIL. His prices are fair, and he's also just a really nice guy. You're a gem Garrett, thank you for serving our community with dedication and love!

From Google

Sarah Jane 1 of 5

In my experience, this business lacks customer service and accountability of their work. I am having issues 6 months after replacing my hot water tank, pressure tank, water pump, and piping ($5k of debt all together- Blue Jay was paid very promptly after their installation). I have asked this business to come out take a look at/fix their work with zero response. A second opinion confirmed my issues are an installation issue and quoted me another $800-1,000 to fix it. Beware ladies: he will not return my phone calls or emails and prefers to only talk to my husband. Do not recommend if you have a manufactured home- they were quite rude about the space being too tight and my home being a "trailer" (it is not mobile). I am left with a lot of debt as a new, first time home owner and loudly tell people in this community not to use this plumber.

Business reply

Blue Jay Plumbing and Heating

Hi Sarah. We apologize for your experience. We pride ourselves at our customer service and prompt address of issues in general especially if it is in any way due to one of our installs. We would love to hear from you as nothing you are describing comes to mind including your name but would be happy to address your concerns. We welcome any and all conversation at anytime so we can find out what this job was and a way tp resolve this for you.

From Google

K. Millsey 5 of 5

Called Garrett with an issue with our hot water heater and he helped us over the phone and solved the issue!! He is a genius!!! Thank you Garrett!

From Google

Lucrative Door 8 5 of 5

The owner is a good guy and will do right by you.

From Google

sandy repp 5 of 5

Nobody likes to have to call a plumber, but I am happy to recommend Blue Jay Plumbing & Heating. Garrett and his team have done several recent plumbing jobs for me, including replacing my hot water heater when it failed. In each instance, Garrett and his team were prompt and professional, showed up when scheduled, did great work, left the place tidy, and came in at or a bit below their estimate. In addition, Garrett is an excellent communicator, returning calls and texts and discussing in detail the work that needs to be done and how it will be accomplished. I trust Blue Jay Plumbing & Heating, I am very satisfied with the work they have done for me, and I recommend them highly.

From Google

Aaron Segal 5 of 5

Garrett is great, he was able to repair rather than replace parts of our very old fuel oil furnace. When we kept hearing pipe knocks, he came back and bled the lines very well. It's great to work with one person rather than a big corporate group.

From Google

Palmer Woodcraft 5 of 5

Garrett Jay is a top notch plumber. He's done extensive re-plumbing work on our 200+ year old house, off and on for the past 2.5 yrs. He's been an excellent communicator throughout the multiphase process. He and crew consistently show up on schedule, perform the work quickly, using best practices, and for a fair price. Garrett is also a good human being and nice to have around. Which matters. As a carpenter who's been working in the trades for over 25 years, having worked in 3 states and multiple foreign countries, I've witnessed quite a spectrum of talent and lack thereof. Garrett is truly top tier. Thanks for all of your great work!

From Google

Jay P 5 of 5

Garrett and his crew are top notch. After a recommendation from a friend, I gave them a call. Not many people were willing to work during a Christmas eve plumbing emergency. Blue Jay Plumbing saved the day and I have had them back for more work since. Super knowledgeable, and honest. Certainly, a good group of people to work with. Would highly recommend!

From Google

John H Palmer Jr Palmer Jr. 5 of 5

Garrett and Blue Jay Plumbing are extremely dedicated to give their customers the best service possible. Their knowledge, experience and professionalism is unmatched by anyone in this area. I would recommend Garrett and his company to anyone! Happy customer, John Palmer

From Google

Fran Manzella 5 of 5

Garrett and his staff did more work for me last November 2023 and this month. They always do an excellent job. They are skilled, professional, knowledgeable and really nice people! I highly recommend this business!! Garrett is amazing. He provided services in my home a few years ago when he worked for someone else. I didn't even realize he was back in town until another business referred him to me. He responded right away and set up a time to evaluate the problem I was having with my air conditioning system. He addressed the issue and saved me tons of money. He is honest, thorough, skilled, explains everything step by step, has reasonable prices, and always tries to do what's best for the customer. I am so thrilled to have him again as a service provider. Thank you Garrett and I'll be calling you again soon!! Positive Responsiveness, Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism, Value Services Service not listed

Showing 20 of 56 reviews

Share your experience

Is this your business?

More plumbers elsewhere in NY

More

Copy this link

We could not copy the link for you. Select the link below and copy it.

Choose a city

Positive and negative reviews

Google reviews of 4 or 5 count as positive. Google reviews of 1 or 2 count as negative. Google reviews of 3 are not counted.

Summary of reviews

AI wrote this summary from the reviews below. It can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

How summaries are made

How summaries are made

AI-generated summary

AI reads the Google reviews shown on this page, up to 300. When there are more, it reads a random sample of 300 with the same mix of star ratings as all the reviews. Each point is something at least 3 reviewers say. It shows how many, and you can open their reviews. Complaints are what reviewers report, not our verdict. We check serious ones before showing them. AI can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

Reviews behind this point

AI-generated summary

Start a new compare list?