East Rochester

Penfield Plumbing & Heating

4.4 of 5

Average of 61 Google reviews

Positive and negative reviews

  • Positive 50 reviews, 82% of all reviews
  • Negative 9 reviews, 15% of all reviews
  • Not counted 2 reviews, 3% of all reviews

Google reviews of 4 or 5 count as positive. Google reviews of 1 or 2 count as negative. Google reviews of 3 are not counted.

AI summary of their website

About Penfield Plumbing & Heating

  • In business: 64 Years (Since 1962)

Penfield Plumbing & Heating is a family-owned plumbing company in its third generation, serving residential and commercial clients in the Rochester area. Established in 1962, it handles new construction plumbing, remodeling, and general plumbing repairs for homes and businesses.

From their website, penfieldplumbing.com, as of October 23, 2026.

These facts are the business's own claims, and FairPipes has not checked them. AI summarized the website and can make mistakes.

What their website says

In business
"Penfield Plumbing & Heating, Inc. was established in 1962."

AI-generated summary

Summary of reviews

AI wrote this summary from the reviews below. It can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

What reviewers like

  1. Professionalism and friendliness

  2. Reasonable or affordable prices

  3. Reviewers praise prompt responses and quick service

  4. Quality of the work

What reviewers dislike

  1. Prices they consider very high

  • Written reviews used: 51
  • Made on October 24, 2026

AI reads the Google reviews shown on this page, up to 300. When there are more, it reads a random sample of 300 with the same mix of star ratings as all the reviews. Each point is something at least 3 reviewers say. It shows how many, and you can open their reviews. Complaints are what reviewers report, not our verdict. We check serious ones before showing them. AI can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

Call (585) 381-5560Visit website

License record

Not checked by FairPipes yet

We do not have license records for New York yet. Look up this business on the state licensing board's website.

Details

Hours
  • Monday to Friday 8:00 am to 5:00 pm
  • Saturday and Sunday Closed

Hours as listed on Google; we have not checked them.

Reviews

From Google

chris mclean 5 of 5

New I definitely would recommend this company for all your plumbing needs. They are efficient, and fairly priced for any job. I will contact them again when the need arises.

From Google

Richard Dickson 5 of 5

Reasonable price | $400–600 A real person answered the phone so the entire experience started well. They were able to come out the next day. The service was friendly, professional and within budget. I will use Penfield Plumbing for my future needs. Services Toilet repair

From Google

Paul Daniels 5 of 5

We needed emergency service for a blockage in our main wastewater system. Their technician came out on Saturday morning and took care of everything. He was kind and thoughtful, careful and thorough. We highly recommend Penfield Plumbing!

From Google

Sam DiPiano 5 of 5

We've had nothing but great experiences with Penfield Plumbing over the years. Most recently, they came out quickly when our hot water tank unexpectedly failed and had a new one installed promptly, making a stressful situation much easier. They've also installed a new garbage disposal, and helped with several other plumbing projects over the years. Every technician has been professional, knowledgeable, and respectful of our home. Their work is always high quality, and we appreciate how reliable and responsive they are. We highly recommend Penfield Plumbing to anyone looking for honest, dependable, and professional plumbing services. Thank you for the excellent service over the years! Services Toilet repair, Water heater installation, Garbage disposal installation, Water heater repair, Garbage disposal repair

From Google

kelly lamendola 5 of 5

We had a issue at our apartment complex that maintenance couldn't fix. They came out and was amazing. He was so nice and fixed out broken pump. 10 stars!

From Google

Andrea Necci 5 of 5

Reasonable price Anthony and Drew are the best!! They always save the day at our office!!! Thank you for the quick response every time :) Services Toilet repair, Plumbing pipe repair

From Google

Jennifer Matic 2 of 5

We have used Penfield Plumbing for over 10 years. They were our 'go-to' company. We had a small pipe leak and called them for help. They told us they could fix it, but only if the main water line was shut off. They said the main shutoff valve wasn’t working and would need to be replaced before they could repair (solder) the pipe. They left without stopping the leak—even though there was a separate shutoff valve just six inches above the damaged section. I discovered that myself the next day. A month later, I had a leak in a different pipe and called a different company. They turned off the main water line with no problem and completed the repair. So I’m still unsure why Penfield Plumbing told me the main shutoff valve needed replacing. I don’t think they were being dishonest—I think it was a mistake. But still, this error cost me time, and could have cost me quite a bit of money. Services Plumbing leak detection, Plumbing pipe repair

From Google

Annemarie Pavia 5 of 5

Lou and Vinnie were great. Awesome plumbers. Awesome guys. Annemarie Pavia

From Google

Gary Goodwin 5 of 5

Reasonable price | $100–200 Penfield plumbing, with speedy response, helped me complete an installation of a garbage disposal. I was unable to complete the job and they came to my assistance. Very friendly and with expertise of many years! Price was reasonable. Services Garbage disposal installation

From Google

Keith Helmicki 5 of 5

Great price | $100–200 Penfield Plumbing is the most efficient, customer service oriented business around! They came to my business quickly and Drew, the service agent they sent was amazingly helpful and friendly and got us up and running quickly!! Thank you!!!

Business reply

Penfield Plumbing & Heating

Hi, Keith! Thank you so much for the feedback, we sincerely appreciate it! I'll make sure Drew and his manager are aware of your wonderful compliment!

From Google

Karl Buechner 2 of 5

Overpriced | $1,000+ In the past I had penfield plumbing do all my work and their quality was never in question. I had a pinging noise in my water heater. They sent out a tech and he said water pressure was too high. He gave me a quote of $1050 to install new regulator and replace expansion tank. I said that seems pretty high and he said it is 4 hours worth of work. I signed the agreement to do the work which was my bad because I trusted them in the past. Two guys were here working for a max of 1 hour and 15 minutes. I was anticipating them being here all morning. I asked where did the 4 hours come from he said it was 2 people which he never explained to me.I said it still didn’t add up to 4 hours and he would not adjust the bill because I signed the agreement for the amount. I called the office because I felt he over estimated and basically got more excuses. I guess the lesson learned is don’t trust anyone and get quotes from others before you sign. PS the work quality was still very good! Services Service not listed

From Google

V Vivian 1 of 5

Office would not give a quote on the service we were having done at our house. They said “he will give you a fair price”. REALLY make the price up as you go?? Who does that?

From Google

Nadine Friedlander 5 of 5

Anytime you need plumbing service ask for Lou! He is the best! Always there to help with your problem! Very friendly, courteous and knowledgeable ! Can’t ask for a better serviceman!

Business reply

Penfield Plumbing & Heating

Thank you very much for the compliments!

From Google

David Gibbons 5 of 5

We’ve been trusting Penfield Plumbing for over a decade, and they never fail to impress! Today, Vinny and Greg provided outstanding service, offering expert advice on issues with two of our bathrooms. Their honesty saved us from unnecessary repairs, delivering an extraordinary client experience. The entire team, no matter who they send, consistently exceeds our expectations with their professionalism and skill. We wholeheartedly recommend Penfield Plumbing for their reliable, top-notch service. This locally owned company is truly exceptional!

Business reply

Penfield Plumbing & Heating

Thank you very much for the feedback. As a family company with a small crew, we truly appreciate it!

From Google

Adam Connors 5 of 5

Reasonable price | $400–500 Penfield Plumbing (and especially Lou) are simply the best! I had a plumbing emergency after hours and was incredibly stressed about what could have turned into a major water flooding issue. Enter Lou from Penfield Plumbing- he not only picked up the phone but immediately put me at ease with his calm, courteous, and professional demeanor. Lou expertly walked me through the situation step-by-step, helped me troubleshoot in real time, identified the cause of the leak, and told me exactly what parts were needed. It was the kind of knowledgeable and compassionate support that’s rare to find these days. What really sets Lou (and Penfield Plumbing) apart is their outstanding communication and friendliness. They scheduled the follow-up work quickly, showed up earlier than expected, clearly explained what needed to be done, and made sure I had a chance to ask questions (which they answered thoroughly and respectfully). The entire experience was smooth, efficient, and far exceeded what I’m used to from service providers. I was so impressed with Lou’s work and overall approach that I’ll be calling Penfield Plumbing for all my future plumbing needs. Professional, prompt, and genuinely kind people- can’t recommend them highly enough!

Business reply

Penfield Plumbing & Heating

Wow, thank you for the heart felt response! Every positive review means the world to us as a family-owned company. Hope to see you for soon for non-emergency work!

From Google

Patricia McLaughlin 5 of 5

Vinny and Greg did an excellent job for us. They removed and replaced a 90 year old concrete utility sink and replaced 2 equally old outdoor faucets. They were prompt, tidy, efficient, polite, and thoroughly professional.

Business reply

Penfield Plumbing & Heating

Hi Patricia! Thank you SO much for the positive feedback! We are a small family company, so every little compliment helps. Thank you for using Penfield Plumbing.

From Google

Trudy Rodean 5 of 5

Penfield Plumbing has served well each time I have requested their assistance. The people sent have been skilled, work efficiently and are pleasant to deal with. I will continue to use this company and will recommend them willingly to any neighbors and friends who need such work to be done.

Business reply

Penfield Plumbing & Heating

Thank you, Trudy for your kind words. Every positive review means so much to our small company!

From Google

Donna Farren 5 of 5

Reasonable price I can't recommend this plumbing service enough! From the moment I called with an emergency, Monica was fantastic; she was so efficient and got me on the schedule right away. Drew showed up incredibly fast and was an absolute lifesaver! His work was top-notch, and he was not only highly skilled but also very respectful and professional throughout. He even made sure to clean up thoroughly after the job was done. This was a huge project and I am super happy with the results! Thank you! Services Plumbing pipe repair, Faucet repair, Faucet installation, Service not listed

Business reply

Penfield Plumbing & Heating

Thank you very much for the positive compliments! We always try our best to serve our customers straightaway. I will definitely pass your compliment on to Drew- I'm sure he will appreciate it!

From Google

Chadwick Hall 5 of 5

From Google

Gizem D 3 of 5

Toilet was leaking to the room below when flushed. This plumber guy - Vinnie came, said toilet bowl alignment issue. Charged $450. Then, as soon as he left, the flush started malfunctioning. We had to call him back. Replaced flush - $210. So this second visit all of a sudden he mentioned toilet bowl had to be replaced, said $700. We didn’t replace it because all these trips were starting to cost too much! After he left, toilet seat was crooked and the water level low! The stuff wasn’t going down. He is coming a 3rd time now. When we called to complain about the incompetence and the ridiculous prices, the dispatcher hung up on us!🎉 Update: 3rd time, Louis came. He was ok. We had Steve before and he was good. Ask for them specifically. I’d be giving 1 star if it wasn’t for these 2.

Showing 20 of 61 reviews

Share your experience

Is this your business?

More plumbers elsewhere in NY

More

Copy this link

We could not copy the link for you. Select the link below and copy it.

Choose a city

Positive and negative reviews

Google reviews of 4 or 5 count as positive. Google reviews of 1 or 2 count as negative. Google reviews of 3 are not counted.

About Penfield Plumbing & Heating

From their website, penfieldplumbing.com, as of October 23, 2026.

These facts are the business's own claims, and FairPipes has not checked them. AI summarized the website and can make mistakes.

What their website says

In business
"Penfield Plumbing & Heating, Inc. was established in 1962."

Summary of reviews

AI wrote this summary from the reviews below. It can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

How summaries are made

How summaries are made

AI-generated summary

AI reads the Google reviews shown on this page, up to 300. When there are more, it reads a random sample of 300 with the same mix of star ratings as all the reviews. Each point is something at least 3 reviewers say. It shows how many, and you can open their reviews. Complaints are what reviewers report, not our verdict. We check serious ones before showing them. AI can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

Reviews behind this point

AI-generated summary

Start a new compare list?