Hobart

Kenneth Muthig Plumbing & Heating

3.5 of 5

Average of 24 Google reviews

Positive and negative reviews

  • Positive 14 reviews, 58% of all reviews
  • Negative 9 reviews, 38% of all reviews
  • Not counted 1 review, 4% of all reviews

Google reviews of 4 or 5 count as positive. Google reviews of 1 or 2 count as negative. Google reviews of 3 are not counted.

AI-generated summary

Summary of reviews

AI wrote this summary from the reviews below. It can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

What reviewers like

  1. Reviewers praise prompt responses to service calls

  2. Team's knowledge

What reviewers dislike

  1. Reviewers report being charged more than other plumbers quoted

  2. Reviewers report not receiving return calls

  • Written reviews used: 21
  • Made on October 24, 2026

AI reads the Google reviews shown on this page, up to 300. When there are more, it reads a random sample of 300 with the same mix of star ratings as all the reviews. Each point is something at least 3 reviewers say. It shows how many, and you can open their reviews. Complaints are what reviewers report, not our verdict. We check serious ones before showing them. AI can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

Call (607) 538-9311Visit website

License record

Not checked by FairPipes yet

We do not have license records for New York yet. Look up this business on the state licensing board's website.

Details

Hours
  • Monday to Friday 8:00 am to 4:00 pm
  • Saturday and Sunday Closed
Social media

Hours as listed on Google; we have not checked them.

Reviews

From Google

Vincent Stephans 1 of 5

Reasonable price | $1,000+ Did all the water and gas and A/C plumbing on my home. Over $20k. Called, over time, for repairs or new work. Never returned a single call. Services Service not listed

From Google

Marian Carney 5 of 5

From Google

Ashley Vasta 5 of 5

From Google

Zachary Wiener 5 of 5

From Google

Summer 1 of 5

They won't return phone calls, apparently they decide if they like you before they perform work.

From Google

Sarah Cuomo 5 of 5

These folks are great! I've used them a couple times for my business and they've been wonderful.

From Google

Mike Maldanado 1 of 5

Do not call this plumber. First of all he has a two tier pricing system, one for the locals and the other for nyc residents. He tried to charge me over 2K for repairs i did not need. He was unable to troubleshoot my problem either. Luckily i went to the hardware store in hobart and asked for a trustworthy person and although he was pretty busy when he made it over he was able to troubleshoot the problem in about 5 minutes and work all day to fix it. He charged me less than 300 dollars. Do yourself a favor and make a trip to the hardware store and the get the numbers of people the locals use.

From Google

jacob Lock 5 of 5

Came out on an emergency Saturday night. They got the job done. Very knowledgeable and courteous. Couldn’t be happier. Positive Responsiveness, Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism Services Water tank repair

From Google

David Kopach 1 of 5

Muthig's arrived for a boiler service call; upon arriving, they jiggled some wires and got the boiler to turn back on. Two days later, our boiler died again, leaving us without heat or hot water on a cold night. Luckily, a friend was able to get us up and running in a day by properly diagnosing the issue (something Muthig's was unable to understand). When calling Muthig's for a repeat call, they rudely refused to admit that they had made a mistake and hung up on me abruptly. This is the most unprofessional and uneducated heating company I have ever dealt with. I cannot recommend them less! Please take your business elsewhere. Negative Quality, Professionalism

From Google

Larry Becker 5 of 5

Had problems with our furnace on Thanksgiving weekend. Called our normal go to company for service many times but could not get anyone to respond. After 2 days and no response Muthig’s was recommended by relatives. We called, they had back within minutes and less than an hour later were on the job. Very knowledgeable and efficient. We so much appreciate the responsiveness. We have other jobs in mind for spring and Muthig’s will be our new Go To heating and plumbing company. Services Plumbing leak repair, Service not listed

From Google

Todd Heyn 5 of 5

If you need work on your furnace, look no further. I have a high bar that I set with contractors and this company not only met that nar but exceeded it on two separate occasions. I can not recommend them high enough. Is there an option for six stars???

From Google

Mary Matus 1 of 5

I have known these people for over 20 years. When my own plumber I hired them to drain the pipes of a house I owned. They charged me more than double what other plumbers told me after the fact. I wrote them a letter and they never responded. I should not have trusted them Negative Value Services Service not listed

From Google

brenda warner 5 of 5

Always prompt and professional!

From Google

Russell Spatafora 5 of 5

I own Rosalino’s diner in Andes New York and have had multiple different issues with appliance and ovens which the Muthigs team has been happy to help with. From multiple odd requests to work on garland ovens to plumbing and heating for a very old furnace everyone has been out to help. I have a lot of old equipment and it gives me a lot of comfort knowing a local business is here to help. Positive Responsiveness, Punctuality, Professionalism Services Service not listed

From Google

Bill Chriswell 5 of 5

Positive Responsiveness, Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism, Value Services Toilet installation, Service not listed

From Google

George Orwell 2 of 5

be careful, has 2-tier pricing. one for locals and other one for city folk. compared to others his skills are very limited. i got a quote from him fro 2K but hired a local guy to do the same work for 250 bucks. Negative Quality, Value Services Plumbing leak detection

From Google

Mark Gosdigian 5 of 5

A+ Fast, professional, knowledgeable and friendly. Couldn’t have asked for a better experience in solving a home heating issue. Josh was the best. Definitely a customer for life.

From Google

Gary C 5 of 5

Called in the afternoon regarding an oil fired boiler issue, received a return call late afternoon, and Josh came early evening. Replaced the aquastat in short order. I will definitely use them again.

From Google

Glen Marin 1 of 5

Came to my home.. Looked around.. Talked about his car.. Told me he would do the job, call back in 2 days with a price..6 days passed, I called him... He said " I don't have any time for you"..and hung up..I would give him zero stars, if I could.

From Google

Jonathan Van Tilburg 5 of 5

Great local plumber and service provider.

Showing 20 of 24 reviews

Share your experience

Is this your business?

More plumbers elsewhere in NY

More

Copy this link

We could not copy the link for you. Select the link below and copy it.

Choose a city

Positive and negative reviews

Google reviews of 4 or 5 count as positive. Google reviews of 1 or 2 count as negative. Google reviews of 3 are not counted.

Summary of reviews

AI wrote this summary from the reviews below. It can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

How summaries are made

How summaries are made

AI-generated summary

AI reads the Google reviews shown on this page, up to 300. When there are more, it reads a random sample of 300 with the same mix of star ratings as all the reviews. Each point is something at least 3 reviewers say. It shows how many, and you can open their reviews. Complaints are what reviewers report, not our verdict. We check serious ones before showing them. AI can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

Reviews behind this point

AI-generated summary

Start a new compare list?