3.2 of 5
Average of 15 Google reviews
Google reviews of 4 or 5 count as positive. Google reviews of 1 or 2 count as negative. Google reviews of 3 are not counted.
AI-generated summary
AI wrote this summary from the reviews below. It can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.
Very high prices
AI reads the Google reviews shown on this page, up to 300. When there are more, it reads a random sample of 300 with the same mix of star ratings as all the reviews. Each point is something at least 3 reviewers say. It shows how many, and you can open their reviews. Complaints are what reviewers report, not our verdict. We check serious ones before showing them. AI can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.
Not checked by FairPipes yet
We do not have license records for New York yet. Look up this business on the state licensing board's website.
From Google
Ben Goldshlager
Overpriced | $600–700 I would NOT RECOMMEND a plumbing outfit that chargeS $400.00/hour to replace a faucet that I provided. Ridiculous, $400 an hour? Do they fix pipes or perform open-heart surgery on them? Total charge, a.k.a robbery, came to $711.00 for 2 (claimed) hours of labor. Services Service not listed
From Google
Shai
I rarely leave reviews, but Montilli Plumbing was such a nightmare I had to warn others. Completely unprofessional from start to finish. They showed up late, didn’t fix the issue properly, and left a huge mess behind. I had to call another plumber to redo their work, which ended up costing me even more. When I tried to call them about it, they were rude and dismissive — no accountability whatsoever. Avoid this company at all costs. Save yourself the stress, money, and frustration.
From Google
Raghunath paul
From Google
Michael Seidman
Workers were good and got the job done. However pricing was deceiving and owner was not transparent with price of the job when we spoke on the phone, and I ended up paying 2x what I was expecting to pay. After admitting that he was not clear on what the cost was, he was still unwilling to change the price to reflect what we discussed. Would not use again, which is disappointing because the workers who came were professional and good.
From Google
alfredo maraw
Be aware, this company does a terrible job, all the time because they just don’t care for the customer. Also be aware, after they give you an estimate they ask you for more money and if you don’t pay the sue you. Simple as like that. You are advised !!!!
From Google
E H
Excellent service, in the area for 50 years.
From Google
Marie Reynolds
Experienced professionals that do the job right and on time. Highly recommend this company!
From Google
Tony Solino
Great service.
From Google
Shira Halevy
Really awesome plumbers! Took care of my huge flood on the weekend!!
From Google
Khosie Stephenson
From Google
pieous peter
The amazing thing is you call they come and the problem will be solved. But pricing is just crazy and your not getting the same guy necessarily twice. They seem legalistically set up for more commercial work but i wouldnt recommend them unless your stuck. Negative Value
From Google
Dragomir Dumitrescu
From Google
James Pepe
Incredibly unpleasant to work with, would not recommend.
From Google
mellowman ace Serrano
From Google
Susan Friedman
Great technician. He was professional and courteous. But the prices for the work is VERY high!! I will not be using them again, nor would I recommend them because of their prices.
From Google
Business reply
A. Montilli Plumbing & Heating
Tap Share in your browser, then Add to Home Screen. No Share button? Tap Menu (three dots) by the address bar first.
Tap Menu (three dots) by the address bar.
See a Share button on the browser bar? Tap it and skip to step 3.
Tap Share in the menu.
Tap Add to Home Screen (scroll down if needed), then Add.
