Garnerville

2.7 of 5

Average of 41 Google reviews

Positive and negative reviews

  • Positive 17 reviews, 42% of all reviews
  • Negative 23 reviews, 56% of all reviews
  • Not counted 1 review, 2% of all reviews

Google reviews of 4 or 5 count as positive. Google reviews of 1 or 2 count as negative. Google reviews of 3 are not counted.

AI-generated summary

Summary of reviews

AI wrote this summary from the reviews below. It can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

What reviewers like

  1. Quality of completed work

  2. Reviewers praise professional and friendly technicians

  3. Prompt, timely service

  4. Fair or reasonable prices

What reviewers dislike

  1. Reviewers report delays, missed visits, or unreliable scheduling

  2. Reviewers report jobs left incomplete or requiring repeated visits

  3. Reviewers report water damage or flooding during or after repairs

  • Written reviews used: 37
  • Made on October 25, 2026

AI reads the Google reviews shown on this page, up to 300. When there are more, it reads a random sample of 300 with the same mix of star ratings as all the reviews. Each point is something at least 3 reviewers say. It shows how many, and you can open their reviews. Complaints are what reviewers report, not our verdict. We check serious ones before showing them. AI can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

Call (845) 786-3000Visit website

License record

Not checked by FairPipes yet

We do not have license records for New York yet. Look up this business on the state licensing board's website.

Details

Hours
  • Monday to Friday 8:00 am to 6:00 pm
  • Saturday and Sunday Closed

Hours as listed on Google; we have not checked them.

Reviews

From Google

Pete Souris 1 of 5

New Dominoes is there now

From Google

G Peterson 1 of 5

Unreliable, barely competent, not trustworthy. I made the mistake of using American Home Shield. This was the only plumber available via AHS. I have had too many miserable and exhausting experiences with both and have since canceled AHS. AVOID at all possible costs!!!

From Google

Brian Safchik 1 of 5

These guys are terrible. They came to my house, said they can do the job, ordered parts and they never came back. I'll never use them again

From Google

Christina Olivo 1 of 5

I put in three separate requests through AHS and apparently this is the only plumber they have. All three times Mr Plumber lied to AHS saying I canceled the appointment. After thinking the first time was an error I submitted again..after the third call from AHS asking if I needed the appointment because I canceled I realized that Mr Plumber was lying and saying I was canceling so they didn't have to do the appointment. How unprofessional. But I see from the reviews I dodged a terrible service. I'll take my business to a reputable company and I canceled AHS because any service that includes a vendor this terrible can't be trusted.

From Google

Roya Gholizadeh 5 of 5

Good experience with Mr. Plumber. We have America HS insurance. When the first vendor gave AHS wrong diagnosis, MR. Plumber came to give second opinion and DID THE JOB on first visit. Thank you!

From Google

Krissy Flannery 5 of 5

Lee and Jim installed all new supply and drain lines to my kitchen. They did an awesome job, were professional and friendly, and the price was very reasonable, job was done in one day. I will absolutely use them again!

From Google

Brandy Ferris 5 of 5

From Google

Harbin Asani 5 of 5

Positive Responsiveness, Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism, Value Services Outdoor plumbing system repair, Toilet repair, Water heater repair

From Google

Rose Ramos 5 of 5

Scott and partner did a great job with my new water heater installation. Fast and well done and my water heater is working perfectly. A pleasure to work with them! Positive Quality Services Water heater installation

From Google

Xiomara Daza 5 of 5

My water heater broke after 17 years and a friend referred me to Scott. I am very please with how responsive he was. He was friendly and gave me all the options I could have. Did the job within days, even offered me a small heater for the mean time, very kind. Installation day was great, on time, detailed and communicative throughout the process. Thank you for my new tankless water heater. So happy to have hot water again and for a friendly professional plumber. Will us him again for future projects. Positive Professionalism

From Google

Maide Mersimi 5 of 5

Positive Responsiveness, Quality Services Sump pump installation, Sump pump repair

From Google

Nisa’s Kid Show 5 of 5

Positive Punctuality, Quality Services Water heater installation, Water heater repair

From Google

Arben Mersimi 5 of 5

Positive Punctuality, Professionalism Services Faucet installation, Shower installation

From Google

Jona “jonac” C.Z 5 of 5

I had a massive leak , i called at 10 am and they came by 1pm and they were done so quickly. Also , to mention they were very respectful. Positive Punctuality, Professionalism Services Plumbing leak repair

From Google

Gloria Trujillo 1 of 5

Negative Responsiveness, Punctuality, Professionalism

From Google

Nijaz Ziba 5 of 5

Was awesome they came and did everything in a timely matter Positive Value Services Faucet installation, Water heater repair, Water tank installation

From Google

Blerta S 5 of 5

Positive Quality, Professionalism, Value Services Faucet installation, Water heater installation, Drain cleaning

From Google

Renee' Ocher 3 of 5

Technician Jim always on time & respectful of my home. Replacement product his company supplied was either defective or wrong fit. Took 5 visits for his boss to agree to change to another brand. Again Jim a 5 Mr. Plumber a 3

From Google

fernando pena 1 of 5

I cannot believe how poorly my grandma was treated Hida Mainer of Mr Plumber was a nightmare to work with He took advantage of my Grandma Charged her five times the going rate Negative Quality

From Google

brendan liebenow 1 of 5

This was the worst customer service experience I have ever received Muamet was completely unprofessional. Stay far away from this company they will try to take advantage of you. Negative Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value

Showing 20 of 41 reviews

Share your experience

Is this your business?

More plumbers in Garnerville, NY

More plumbers elsewhere in NY

More

Copy this link

We could not copy the link for you. Select the link below and copy it.

Choose a city

Positive and negative reviews

Google reviews of 4 or 5 count as positive. Google reviews of 1 or 2 count as negative. Google reviews of 3 are not counted.

Summary of reviews

AI wrote this summary from the reviews below. It can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

How summaries are made

How summaries are made

AI-generated summary

AI reads the Google reviews shown on this page, up to 300. When there are more, it reads a random sample of 300 with the same mix of star ratings as all the reviews. Each point is something at least 3 reviewers say. It shows how many, and you can open their reviews. Complaints are what reviewers report, not our verdict. We check serious ones before showing them. AI can make mistakes, so read the reviews too.

Reviews behind this point

AI-generated summary

Start a new compare list?